2021-01-30 04:58:28
Social media services including Facebook and Reddit restrict discussions about weapons, drugs and other illegal activity, but their rules do not specifically mention another lucrative regulated good: stocks.
Some people think they should. Users of a Reddit group, in which five million members exchange investment ideas, generated significant profits by gorging on shares of GameStop and other out-of-favour companies that had been shorted by big hedge funds.
Investors have used social media for years. Anonymous posts have fuelled cryptocurrency pump and dump schemes, according to studies, but that obscure market generated less scrutiny. The “Reddit rally” however, has roiled global stock markets and drawn scrutiny of posts in which thousands of smaller investors trade tips on platforms from Facebook to Instagram to Telegram and Clubhouse.
Individual investors won praise from elected officials and the general public for jabbing powerful hedge funds with a “short squeeze.” Yet critics have emerged, accusing social media users of manipulating markets unlawfully by pumping shares of weak companies. The manager of one Facebook trading community said she has turned down requests to tout individual stocks.
Social media companies are generally not liable for user activity under a statute commonly known as Section 230. Still, their rules bar illegal behaviour like facilitating gun and drug transactions or distributing offensive content that could rile advertisers or generate calls for tighter regulation.
Section 230 also has some carve-outs that in theory could lead to a tech company being penalised for user-generated content, including violations of federal criminal law, said Jeff Kosseff, a cybersecurity law scholar who wrote a book on the law.
He noted that the bar is high. The speech itself would need to be a criminal violation of a law that explicitly specified distribution of that speech as illegal.
In addition, First Amendment precedents typically hold that the companies must have knowledge of criminal speech posted on their platforms in order to be held responsible for it, said Kosseff.
Harvard Law School professor Jesse Fried said the stock trading forums appear to be “purely legal behaviour: irrationally exuberant buying by amateur investors.”
Prosecuting users for deceiving investors is tough but possible, said University of California, Berkeley law professor Stavros Gadinis, adding that social media companies should have the same ability stock market operators do to intervene to stop alleged manipulation.
Identifying bad actors among the frenzy is a challenge. “There’s all of these feedback loops and incentives behind the scenes,” said Sinan Aral, director of the MIT Initiative on the Digital Economy. “We don’t know exactly who was in the crowd.”
The vast majority of traffic on Stocktwits, a social media platform for investors, appears to be people talking about stocks without evidence of manipulation, said Rishi Khanna, its CEO. He said the platform was not taking any extra moderation actions on this activity.
Grey area
Although Reddit has stated platform-wide rules – including no illegal content or soliciting or facilitating illegal transactions – the service relies heavily on community-based moderation. Users who act as moderators make and enforce guidelines about what is permissible.
The founder of the WallStreetBets Reddit community Jaime Rogozinski, who was a moderator of the group until April 2020, said he tried to draw lines on what to allow. He said he and other moderators removed illegal attempts to game the market, such as claiming to have insider information. When there were grey areas, he said they played it safe.
“You’d have attempts for pumping up stock and I still to this day am not sure what the regulation was, but I never wanted to find out,” said Rogozinski.
Archived copies of the forum showed a ban on “market manipulation” topped its list of rules by April last year. The current moderators said they struggled to moderate the WallStreetBets group as traffic surged, briefly causing technical errors at Reddit this week.
A spokeswoman said earlier this week that Reddit would “review and cooperate with valid law enforcement investigations or actions as needed.”
Discord, which hosts many trading discussions, said its rules bar users from engaging in “any illegal behaviour.” Discord on Thursday said it was working with the “Wallstreetbets” room team to moderate its new server, after removing the previous server over hate speech and misinformation. It did not address stock market influence.
A lack of closer scrutiny on the matter has left open the opportunity for potential manipulation. Former Merrill Lynch financial adviser Cassandra Cummings, 47, who now manages 80,000-member Facebook trading group The Stocks and Stilettos Society, said she declined multiple requests in the last year to rally her group around a specific stock.
“They know that I have the power through my group to move that company stock price,” she said.
© Thomson Reuters 2021
What will be the most exciting tech launch of 2021? We discussed this on Orbital, our weekly technology podcast, which you can subscribe to via Apple Podcasts, Google Podcasts, or RSS, download the episode, or just hit the play button below.
wellbutrin online wellbutrin 150mg without prescription wellbutrin 300mg united kingdom
buy viagra alabama – http://viardos.com/ online pharmacy canada
scandinavian shop viagra pris viagra apoteket är viagra receptfritt i polen
vad gör viagra
elimite
buy viagra virginia – http://viavigra.com/ the canadian pharmacy
wellbutrin uk wellbutrin 300 mg generic wellbutrin 150 mg tablet
canada meds viagra – buy viagra pennsylvania cheap viagra online canadian pharmacy
http://canadianvolk.com
sildenafil for women – http://shpilipills.com/ cheap viagra online canadian pharmacy
zanaflex 4mg usa zanaflex otc zanaflex 2 mg medication
viagra without doctor prescription – buy viagra no prescription canada pharmacy online
buy viagra soft 20mg – buy viagra missouri canadian pharmacy xanax
buy kamagra 100mg oral jelly
buy viagra cheap – http://viardos.com/ canadian pharmacy meds review
cialis 5 mg online pharmacy coversyl cialis
sildenafil best dosage – http://viavigra.com/ viagra canadian pharmacy
http://bambulapharmacy.com
http://canadianvolk.com
buy viagra tennessee – http://viavigra.com/ canadian pharmacy reviews
online viagra – http://shpilipills.com/ cialis canadian pharmacy
online pharmacy viagra – http://viardos.com/ walmart pharmacy
canadian pharmacy online cialis – http://pharmedplls.com/ canadian pharmacy cialis 20mg
canadian drugs – http://pharmedplls.com/ cheap viagra online canadian pharmacy
buy online viagra – sildenafil citrate 50mg canadian pharmacies
cialis canada purchase
cheap online viagra sales
viagra prescription online cheap tem Acepe
where to buy wellbutrin where can i buy wellbutrin 150mg wellbutrin 300 mg for sale
sildenafil citrate 50mg – http://shpilipills.com/ canadian drugs pharmacy
brand viagra no presciption
what does female viagra do
levitra price viagra tem Acepe
canadian family pharmacy – http://pharmedplls.com/ cvs pharmacy online
wellbutrin 150mg online wellbutrin nz wellbutrin 300 mg uk
wellbutrin 150 mg pharmacy wellbutrin prices wellbutrin 300mg australia
viagra mail order – site canadian pharmacy world coupon code
buy discount viagra – http://viardos.com/ ed drugs online
buy viagra louisiana – generic viagra india canada drugs online reviews
zanaflex without a prescription zanaflex coupon zanaflex 2 mg tablets
non prescription viagra – buy viagra florida pharmacy course
sample viagra – sildenafil citrate 50 mg visit poster’s website
buy viagra on the street
viagra gift card
when does tadalafil go generic tem Acepe
wellbutrin online wellbutrin cheap wellbutrin 300 mg for sale
free trial of viagra – http://viardos.com/ canadian pharmacy phone number
wellbutrin 150mg online cheap wellbutrin wellbutrin 300mg australia
is buying viagra on the internet safe
viagra quick tabs
cialis 10 mg when to take tem Acepe
buy pfizer viagra online – Generic viagra cheap online drugstore
cialis prescription coupon
retin a micro order
viagra 100mg generic
womens viagra cost in chennai tem Acepe
ed drug – http://pharmedplls.com/ walmart online pharmacy
wellbutrin tablet wellbutrin online wellbutrin united kingdom
wellbutrin 300mg otc cost of wellbutrin 300 mg wellbutrin united states
order viagra us – http://shpilipills.com/ online drugstore
payday loans in houston texas
zanaflex 2 mg usa zanaflex tablet zanaflex medication
wellbutrin 150mg online wellbutrin 300mg pills cheap wellbutrin 150 mg
ivermectin coronavirus
canadian discount pharmacy – canadian drug stores the canadian pharmacy
cheap kamagra tablets uk
viagra mail order usa – viagra cost buy drugs from canada
real viagra pharmacy prescription – http://shpilipills.com/ pharmacy canadian
tadalafil canada generic over the counter
cheap viagra online canadian pharmacy – http://viardos.com/ canadian pharmacy 24
http://canadian2pharmacy.com
walmart pharmacy – site viagra canadian pharmacy
costco online pharmacy – canadian pharmacy sarasota cvs pharmacy online
http://canadianvolk.com
buy viagra mississippi – cost viagra canada drugs
http://bambulapharmacy.com
acticin cream buy
cialis for sale canada cialis vs viagra vs levitra cost
what is tadalafil: http://tadalafilonline20.com/ tadalafil
40 mg tadalafil tadalafil gel
buy tadalafil us
buy prescription drugs online without india pharmacy
meds without a doctor prescription pills without a doctor prescription
usa pharmacy india pills without a doctor prescription
generic pills without a doctor prescription buy cheap prescription drugs online
buy viagra online usa buy real viagra online
viagra without a doctor prescription
viagra amazon 100mg viagra
buy generic 100mg viagra online
п»їviagra pills buy generic 100mg viagra online
generic viagra walmart
online doctor prescription for viagra mexican viagra
viagra online usa
п»їviagra pills when will viagra be generic
where can i buy viagra over the counter
price of viagra order viagra online
where can i buy viagra over the counter
buy viagra online usa where to buy viagra
order viagra online
buy real viagra online order viagra online
buy real viagra online
viagra over the counter order viagra online
viagra discount
buy valtrex without get a prescription online otc valtrex for sale
buy online pharmacy
http://propeciafavdr.com/ – buy finasteride
overcoming ed
zithromax 500 mg lowest price pharmacy online can i buy zithromax over the counter in canada
do i have ed
mexican viagra https://viagrapills100.com/ cheap viagra online
viagra price https://viagrapills100.com/ buying viagra online
online doctor prescription for viagra https://viagrapills100.com/ order viagra online
viagra discount https://viagrapills100.com/ buying viagra online
buy real viagra online https://viagrapills100.com/ how much is viagra
erection pills viagra online cheap ed pills
cheap ed pills from india
cheap erectile dysfunction pills online cheap ed pills in mexico
online ed medications
cheap ed pills usa buy ed pills from canada
cheap ed pills from canada
https://gabapentinst.com/# buy neurontin uk
http://gabapentinst.com/# neurontin medication
http://hydroxychloroquinest.com/# hydroxychloroquine sulfate tablets
prednisone cost 10mg: prednisone 20 mg generic – price of prednisone 5mg
http://zithromaxst.com/# buy zithromax online cheap
http://prednisonest.com/# prednisone daily use
http://hydroxychloroquinest.com/# cost of plaquenil in us
zithromax 250 mg tablet price: where to get zithromax – where can i get zithromax
http://zithromaxproff.com/# where can i get zithromax over the counter
can i buy zithromax over the counter
https://zithromaxproff.com/# can i buy zithromax over the counter in canada
can i buy zithromax over the counter
http://zithromaxproff.com/# can i buy zithromax over the counter in canada
order zithromax without prescription
order sumycin: generic cipro
tinidazole price
nitrofurantoin price: suprax price
biaxin tablets
meds from india: best india pharmacy all generic meds from india
trusted india online pharmacies: buy medication online from india indian online pharmacies review
india pharmacy without dr prescriptions: india pharmacies shipping to usa all generic meds from india
online medications from india: meds from india ordering medicine from india
buy prescriptions from india pharmacy: generic pills india trusted india online pharmacies
cialis pills: https://edpillsonline24.com/# best erectile dysfunction pills
top erectile dysfunction pills: order erectile dysfunction pills online order erectile dysfunction pills
ed pills for sale: https://edpillsonline24.com/# male erectile pills
mail order erectile dysfunction pills: ed pills cialis pills online
ed pills: https://edpillsonline24.com/# male erectile pills
viagra prescription: viagra online no prescription buying viagra online without prescription
buy viagra non prescription viagra viagra without a prescription
senior dating site
local single
viagra without a doctor prescription usa: viagra online no prescription buy viagra without prescription
generic viagra without a doctor prescription viagra without a doctor prescription usa viagra no prescription
free online dating sites
free personals
doxycycline prices: buy doxycycline online 270 tabs – doxycycline 500mg
http://diflucanst.com/# diflucan online cheap without a prescription
amoxicillin discount coupon: amoxicillin without a doctors prescription – amoxicillin script
https://amoxilst.com/# buy amoxicillin online with paypal
diflucan 100 mg tab: generic diflucan prices – diflucan tablets online
https://amoxilst.com/# buy amoxicillin from canada
diflucan over the counter singapore: diflucan 150 price – diflucan canada prescription
http://edpillsonline24.online/# mens ed pills
buy lasix online: cheap furosemide – furosemide
male ed pills: erection pills – erectile dysfunction pills