EU Seeks to Overturn $15.8 Billion Apple Tax Ruling, Calls it ‘Contradictory’


2021-02-01 13:20:27

The European Union is seeking to overturn Apple’s victory in a 13 billion-euro ($15.8 billion) (roughly Rs. 1,15 lakh crore) tax dispute, saying judges used “contradictory reasoning” when they found that the company’s Irish units weren’t liable for huge payments. A summary of the appeal published Monday shows the EU’s determination to challenge the critical July court judgment. The decision was a dramatic setback to Commissioner Margrethe Vestager’s probes of national tax rulings that she says were an illegal subsidy for some large multinational firms.

Slapping Apple with a multi-billion order in 2016 was a landmark case for Vestager, showing she had no fear of upsetting the world’s most valuable tech company or the US Treasury. The move helped fuel an EU push to close tax loopholes that allowed some multinational companies to legally pay less tax in Europe.

The EU said that the lower court improperly conflated Apple’s lack of employees at two Irish units and the company’s level of responsibility for intellectual property on iPhone and iPad sales across Europe. Judges failed to properly weigh the EU’s analysis of the Irish branches and showed “contradictory reasoning” in a separate part of their findings.

Apple declined to immediately comment.

At the heart of the legal arguments are simple questions on where value is created and where it should be taxed. Apple argued that all important decisions on Apple products are made at the company’s Cupertino headquarters and that profits should be taxed in the US Apple had delayed returning international profits to the US for years, citing high costs, until changes to the tax code saw it start repatriating foreign earnings in 2018.

‘Far-Reaching Consequences’

July’s surprise judgment backing that view caused “far-reaching consequences,” Vestager said last year. Apple’s Irish units recorded almost all profits from sales outside the Americas, she said, and treating parent and group companies separately allows businesses to “have their cake and eat it” by reducing tax payments.

Nicole Robins, a partner at economics consultancy Oxera in Brussels, said that while losing the appeal “would be a major setback” for the commission, it wouldn’t necessarily stop it from pursuing other investigations of multinationals’ tax arrangements.

But she said a defeat would force investigators “to adopt a far higher standard of evidence in order to demonstrate that such tax rulings confer an economic advantage to the multinational in question and therefore constitute illegal state aid.” It would also raise the bar on the level of economic and financial evidence needed from the commission, she said.

European governments are increasingly unsympathetic to how companies have been using rules on intellectual property licensing to avoid high tax rates on corporate income. Vestager investigated a slew of technology and branded merchandise firms, from Amazon.com Inc. to Starbucks, that based units in EU countries with favorable tax policies, such as Ireland, Luxembourg and the Netherlands.

The EU is now weighing a tax to target revenue, and not profits, generated by digital companies if global efforts to overhaul corporate taxation don’t make progress. Tax is only one part of an EU crackdown against technology companies that face potential regulation to curb their services and bear more responsibility for the content on their platforms.

(Updates with additional comments from eighth paragraph)

© 2021 Bloomberg L.P.


What will be the most exciting tech launch of 2021? We discussed this on Orbital, our weekly technology podcast, which you can subscribe to via Apple Podcasts, Google Podcasts, or RSS, download the episode, or just hit the play button below.

 



Source link

71 Comments

  1. LbsxGroom February 3, 2021
  2. Jbnbsting February 4, 2021
  3. KbcxZece February 5, 2021
  4. JbbvGroom February 5, 2021
  5. AhkdGroom February 6, 2021
  6. Aqcfcupecteds February 7, 2021
  7. FqhhGroom February 8, 2021
  8. Fvfcsnopy February 10, 2021
  9. LabxGroom February 10, 2021
  10. Nncssnopy February 10, 2021
  11. Jbnvsting February 11, 2021
  12. KvaxZece February 12, 2021
  13. JbbnGroom February 12, 2021
  14. AhbzGroom February 13, 2021
  15. FqbbGroom February 16, 2021
  16. Nbnhsnopy February 18, 2021
  17. Fbsgsnopy February 18, 2021
  18. KndnZece February 27, 2021
  19. WesleyUtiff March 5, 2021
  20. MarcosEtess March 5, 2021
  21. Michaelhom March 8, 2021
  22. Michaelhom March 9, 2021
  23. Michaelhom March 10, 2021
  24. JeffreyGog March 11, 2021
  25. JeffreyGog March 12, 2021
  26. Wayneweday March 14, 2021
  27. JeffreyGog March 14, 2021
  28. JeffreyGog March 15, 2021
  29. Wayneweday March 15, 2021
  30. Ricardomus March 16, 2021
  31. Stanleycak March 16, 2021
  32. Stanleycak March 17, 2021
  33. ThomasHaf March 18, 2021
  34. ThomasHaf March 19, 2021
  35. Ricardomus March 20, 2021
  36. ThomasHaf March 20, 2021
  37. ElmerJearo March 22, 2021
  38. MarvinHag March 23, 2021
  39. ElmerJearo March 23, 2021
  40. Jasoncok March 25, 2021
  41. warnings for vardenafil maximum dose March 26, 2021
  42. Jasoncok March 26, 2021
  43. MarvinHag March 28, 2021
  44. Jasoncok March 28, 2021
  45. alprostadil use after heart surgery March 28, 2021
  46. canadian generic sildenafil March 29, 2021
  47. generic tadalafil united states March 29, 2021
  48. Scottrhync March 29, 2021
  49. Scottrhync March 31, 2021
  50. Frankhem April 1, 2021
  51. Scottrhync April 1, 2021
  52. Scottrhync April 3, 2021
  53. Charlesget April 4, 2021
  54. Stevenstazy April 4, 2021
  55. Stevenstazy April 6, 2021
  56. Charlesget April 6, 2021
  57. Alfredted April 7, 2021
  58. BillyViz April 7, 2021
  59. Alfredted April 8, 2021
  60. BillyViz April 8, 2021
  61. BillyViz April 9, 2021
  62. JamesBrivy April 10, 2021
  63. Timothyjak April 11, 2021
  64. JamesBrivy April 11, 2021
  65. Timothyjak April 11, 2021
  66. JamesBrivy April 15, 2021
  67. Robertovob April 16, 2021
  68. JamesBrivy April 16, 2021
  69. JamesBrivy April 17, 2021
  70. Roberttoike April 17, 2021
  71. Roberttoike April 19, 2021

Leave a Reply